Memoirs of A Geisha by Arthur Golden

9/10

Memoirs of A Geisha is a fictional story that focuses on the life of a young geisha named Sayuri. Initially torn from her impoverished and dilapidated home by the sea in Japan, she is thrown into an okiya (a home for training and practicing geisha) hundreds of miles away and forced to conform to a life and being dedicated to becoming a geisha. The story is set in the 1930s and 40s. It is written by Arthur Golden, who interviewed a geisha named Mineko Iwasaki and used her life story as inspiration. A geisha is essentially a teahouse (social gathering place, but for the wealthy) hostess trained in many arts. For example, a geisha must learn to play numerous instruments, as well as learn how to sing and dance. In Japan, the most prominent geishas were looked upon as though they were celebrities. If someone saw them walking by (in their beautiful makeup and garb) they would bow as low as possible, exhibiting utmost respect and admiration.

Prior to reading the story, I knew little to nothing about the geisha community in Japan, or the role that it played socially. I thought that geishas were mainly prostitutes, but soon found out that their true role was to host (mostly wealthy) individuals during their visits to teahouses. I was also unaware of how complicated and stressful the role of a geisha is. Differentiation between geisha is primarily a matter of artistic and social skills. Therefore, in order to stand out, a geisha must work extremely hard in her studies. And, when it comes to attracting a danna (a wealthy and typically prominent business figure who supports a geisha in return for entertainment and sometimes prostitution), a geisha must find a balance between taking too many social risks and acting sweet and submissive. While Sayuri’s startling blue eyes helped attract many men (as well as geisha competition), accomplishing her place among well-known geisha was no easy task. Achieving a respectable title was hindered by okiya competition, training school, and the second World War (which I will discuss later), all while attempting to find a long lost sister and emotionally supporting herself after her parents’ deaths. Her story of struggle is inspirational, and the theme of traditional Japanese customs is fascinating.

Golden’s story, written as though it was a voice recording of Mineko Iwasaki reflecting upon her career, conveys a balanced amount of historical references and personal experiences. The book immersed me into Sayuri’s world–a young girl, torn from her family, and placed in an alien city. I loved the fact that as Sayuri comes to appreciate the world of geisha, so do I. The story is no tear-jerking-hysterical-thrilling-rollercoaster of a novel, but it is a fresh perspective that I had never thought to come across. My life and Sayuri’s are starkly different, but in that feeling I have found a fascination with the traditional societies of Japan that I have been living alongside and yet I have been so unaware of. I have enjoyed reading Sayuri’s story in Memoirs of A Geisha, and look forward to sharing more.

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “Memoirs of A Geisha by Arthur Golden

  1. jamiekoj

    Hi Penny! I just wanted to let you know I’ve heard that Memoirs of a Geisha is not 100% accurate. While I’m not well versed on the topic, here’s an article the new york times did on it: http://www.nytimes.com/2001/06/19/books/arts-abroad-a-geisha-a-successful-novel-and-a-lawsuit.html. And here’s a tumblr post someone wrote about it which caught my attention (may not be 100% accurate either cause it’s tumblr, but definitely a good reference for things to fact check) http://stevonnie-sandals.tumblr.com/post/149982406529/geisha-are-absolutely-not-prostitutes-btw.

    The tumblr post recommends reading “Geisha, A Life” by Mineko Iwasaki instead, as it is a first hand account by a Geisha rather than a novel written by a white man.

    Again, not an expert on the subject, but I thought you and others interested in reading the book would want to be aware that the facts in the book should be considered with a grain of salt.

  2. penelopespurr

    Second Half:

    I have to admit that I enjoyed the second half of the storyline less than the first half, mostly because the ending was unrealistic and too much of a perfect, predictable “happily ever after” resolution. Ending aside, I enjoyed Arthur Golden’s writing. The fluidity of dialogue and relatability to the characters kept me interested and aware.

    One significant theme in Memoirs of A Geisha is the stark difference between a geisha’s personal and social personalities. While Sayuri was emotional and almost completely uncensored in her okiya and with her mentor geisha, she was careful not to mention any personal feelings that might negatively impact her reputation at social events. And, considering the two facts that 1) Sayuri was expected to contribute to gossip at events and 2) there was immense competition between geisha, constructing a trustworthy and yet social personality proved to be quite difficult. This reminds me, surprisingly, of Schindler’s List. In the book, Oskar Schindler built strong bonds with German Nazi officials in order to keep his company in business, but had to hide his personal ties and hidden Jewish employees. Both characters knew that if they made the slightest mistake during a conversation, they could lose everything they had worked toward (and, in Schindler’s case, his life). Golden’s intentional perspective of Sayuri paints a picture of her variety of personalities and relationships within the geisha community.

    I enjoyed reading Memoirs of A Geisha. I would like to point out that the book not only has (for the most part) an interesting storyline, but also a significant amount of Japanese cultural references (which I have discussed before). If you are interested in the book, please keep in mind that reading Memoirs of A Geisha not only involves appreciation for the story, but a willingness to learn about a mysterious and unique culture. I highly suggest reading Memoirs of A Geisha because it is a captivating reading experience unlike any other!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s